Connect with us

Evidence for student-centered teaching: A process evaluation of MTB- MLE classroom instruction

Authors

Cristian Narvacan – University of the Philippines Diliman

Cite

Narvacan C., (2023). Evidence for student-centered teaching: A process evaluation of MTB- MLE classroom instruction. Journal of Innovation and Research in Primary Education | 2(2), 2023 | 67-77. https://doi.org/10.56916/jirpe.v2i2.558. Retrieved from: https://phedro.org/international-large-scale-assessment-ilsa/

Abstract

Over a decade into the implementation of Mother Tongue-Based Multilingual Education (MTB-MLE) in the Philippines, program implementers continue to encounter challenges, especially in terms of student-centered instruction (SCI). To ensure a student-centered program, the Department of Education crafted guiding principles to which MTB-MLE teaching and learning should be anchored. However, numerous implementation challenges could potentially affect the application of SCI in the classroom. Utilizing process evaluation adopted from Stufflebeam’s (2000) CIPP model, this study investigated the extent to which MTB-MLE teachers carry out SCI in a public elementary school. This paper also examined teachers’ challenges and coping strategies in relation to classroom instruction. Results revealed that SCI was strongly implemented in the MTB-MLE classes. Further, the following SCI-related challenges emerged: (1) learners’ unruly behavior during activities;(2) difficulty in the use of mother tongue; and (3) lack of cooperation among students. To address these concerns, the teachers employed coping strategies, such as setting clear classroom rules, using translation and code-switching, and providing varied activities to match learners’ interests. The findings of this paper may aid policymakers, curriculum designers, and school administrators in developing appropriate programs and activities aimed at enhancing teachers‟ competence to implement a student-centered MTB-MLE education.

Introduction

The Mother Tongue-Based Multilingual Education (MTB-MLE) was officially implemented in the Philippines in the School Year 2012-2013. Republic Act No. 10533 or the Enhanced Basic Education Act of 2013 provided MTB-MLE‟s primary legal basis, which made it part of the K to 12 Basic Education program of the country. The advent of the MTB-MLE program signified the end of the Philippines‟ long tradition of bilingual education (Adriano et al., 2021). According to UNESCO (2022), multilingual education based on the mother tongue or native language is essential for attaining an inclusive and quality education for all learners. Furthermore, it empowers mother languages and “helps preserve the wealth of cultural and traditional heritage that is embedded in every language” (para. 2).

 

The Department of Education (DepEd) points out that MTB-MLE is the key to producing Filipino learners who are multilingual, multiliterate, and multicultural. Since knowledge and skills transfer across languages, it is best for learners to begin their education in the language that they are most familiar with. Once a strong foundation in the mother tongue is developed, learners are better disposed to learn through other languages (DepEd, 2016). Furthermore, DepEd (2016) claims that MTB-MLE (1) facilitates the integration of prior knowledge and new knowledge, (2) fosters critical thinking, (3) constructs a solid bridge toward fluency and oral proficiency in L2, (4) provides L2 support through the L1, (5) supports teaching for meaning and accuracy, and (6) builds confidence and proficiency development in all languages in the classroom, especially in the use of mother tongue.

 

Presently, the mother tongue under MTB-MLE is a subject from Grade 1 to Grade 3 and a medium of instruction (MOI) from kindergarten to Grade 3. As a subject, Mother Tongue aims at the development of, among others, critical thinking, oral competence and confidence, and knowledge of language structure. However, Mother Tongue may be put to an end soon as DepEd revealed its plan to abandon the subject and focus more on its use as an MOI instead (Pinlac, 2022). On the other hand, the use of the mother tongue as a language of instruction starts at the kindergarten level and is applied in the teaching of all learning areas except in English and Filipino subjects. As an MOI, mother tongue targets better comprehension of academic content, curriculum mastery, and creative and critical thinking among learners.


MTB-MLE has been around for many years now as part of the K to 12 curriculum. According to Monje et al. (2021), the program is set on a sound pedagogical base and operates under the principles of learner-centered education. This solid pedagogical foundation and learner-centered learning are encapsulated in the set of guiding principles for MTB-MLE teaching and learning put forward by DepEd (2016), in which principles like discovery learning and active learning are included. In fact, there‟s a growing body of evidence supporting the claim that MTB-MLE promotes a learner-centered classroom (Asia Multilingual Education Group, 2014) where “learners engage more, respond to teachers‟ questions, and participate as equals” (p. 6).


The program may be firmly anchored in sound theoretical bases and principles, but MTB-MLE‟s implementation continues to be faced with numerous challenges and problems (Monje et al., 2021) that could potentially affect the realization of those principles in the classroom, especially in terms of instruction (Aperocho, 2023). MTB-MLE instruction relates to teachers‟ knowledge and competence in pedagogy and content, and proficiency in the MOI (Pradilla et al., 2017). Malone and Malone (2011) emphasized the need for teachers to be equipped with adequate pedagogical competence and language proficiency for the successful implementation of MTB-MLE. However, MTB-MLE studies in the country continue to emphasize the lack of quality and continuous teacher training to improve classroom instruction (see Lartec et al., 2014; Anudin, 2018). Other challenges that hamper MTB-MLE’s implementation in the Philippines include multilingual environment, translation issues, inadequacy of instructional materials, and mandatory compliance with DepEd orders to be the primary reasons for implementation difficulties (Cabansag, 2016).

Full Text

You need to Login or Register an account before accessing this content.

Advertisement
Evaluating the Effectiveness of Professional Development Programs for Junior High School Mathematics Teachers in Improving Mathematics Instruction in the K to 12 Curriculum in the Philippines
Curriculum and Instruction1 year ago

Evaluating the Effectiveness of Professional Development Programs for Junior High School Mathematics Teachers in Improving Mathematics Instruction in the K to 12 Curriculum in the Philippines

International large-scale assessment (ILSA)
Assessment and Evaluation1 year ago

International large-scale assessment (ILSA): Implications for pre-service teacher education in the Philippines

Google Classroom in Graduate Education Its Effectiveness and Challenges
Assessment and Evaluation1 year ago

Google Classroom in Graduate Education: Its Effectiveness and Challenges in An Island University in The Central Philippines

Assessment of Tertiary Education Readiness of the Pioneering Senior HighSchool Graduates in a Private Higher Education Institution in NorthernMindanao, Philippines (1) (PDF) Assessment of Tertiary Education Readiness of the Pioneering Senior High School Graduates in a Private Higher Education Institution in Northern Mindanao.
Assessment and Evaluation1 year ago

Assessment of Tertiary Education Readiness of the Pioneering Senior High School Graduates in a Private Higher Education Institution in Northern Mindanao, Philippines

Multivariate Analysis on Curriculum Viability, Teaching Competence, and Effective Instruction: Davao Region Teachers in Focus
Curriculum and Instruction1 year ago

Multivariate Analysis on Curriculum Viability, Teaching Competence, and Effective Instruction: Davao Region Teachers in Focus

Evidence for student-centered teaching A process evaluation of
Curriculum and Instruction1 year ago

Evidence for student-centered teaching: A process evaluation of MTB- MLE classroom instruction

The Mathematics Teaching Performance of Scholar Education Graduates in Selected Public Schools in the Philippines: An Explanatory Sequential Mixed Method Study
Teaching Pedagogies1 year ago

The Mathematics Teaching Performance of Scholar Education Graduates in Selected Public Schools in the Philippines An Explanatory Sequential Mixed Method Study

Capacity Building of Teacher handling Alternative Delivery Mode (ADM) classes in Zamboanga City Division
Early childhood education1 year ago

Capacity Building of Teacher handling Alternative Delivery Mode (ADM) classes in Zamboanga City Division

Unite for Education: Join PHEDRO as a Founding Member
Uncategorized1 year ago

Join PHEDRO as a Founding Member

Turkey’s Internationalization Of Higher Education Expectation, Experience, And Evaluation Of International Students_compressed
Assessment and Evaluation1 year ago

Turkey’s Internationalization of Higher Education: Expectation, Experience, and Evaluation of International Students

Evaluating the Effectiveness of Professional Development Programs for Junior High School Mathematics Teachers in Improving Mathematics Instruction in the K to 12 Curriculum in the Philippines
Curriculum and Instruction1 year ago

Evaluating the Effectiveness of Professional Development Programs for Junior High School Mathematics Teachers in Improving Mathematics Instruction in the K to 12 Curriculum in the Philippines

International large-scale assessment (ILSA)
Assessment and Evaluation1 year ago

International large-scale assessment (ILSA): Implications for pre-service teacher education in the Philippines

Google Classroom in Graduate Education Its Effectiveness and Challenges
Assessment and Evaluation1 year ago

Google Classroom in Graduate Education: Its Effectiveness and Challenges in An Island University in The Central Philippines

Assessment of Tertiary Education Readiness of the Pioneering Senior HighSchool Graduates in a Private Higher Education Institution in NorthernMindanao, Philippines (1) (PDF) Assessment of Tertiary Education Readiness of the Pioneering Senior High School Graduates in a Private Higher Education Institution in Northern Mindanao.
Assessment and Evaluation1 year ago

Assessment of Tertiary Education Readiness of the Pioneering Senior High School Graduates in a Private Higher Education Institution in Northern Mindanao, Philippines

Multivariate Analysis on Curriculum Viability, Teaching Competence, and Effective Instruction: Davao Region Teachers in Focus
Curriculum and Instruction1 year ago

Multivariate Analysis on Curriculum Viability, Teaching Competence, and Effective Instruction: Davao Region Teachers in Focus

Evidence for student-centered teaching A process evaluation of
Curriculum and Instruction1 year ago

Evidence for student-centered teaching: A process evaluation of MTB- MLE classroom instruction

The Mathematics Teaching Performance of Scholar Education Graduates in Selected Public Schools in the Philippines: An Explanatory Sequential Mixed Method Study
Teaching Pedagogies1 year ago

The Mathematics Teaching Performance of Scholar Education Graduates in Selected Public Schools in the Philippines An Explanatory Sequential Mixed Method Study

Capacity Building of Teacher handling Alternative Delivery Mode (ADM) classes in Zamboanga City Division
Early childhood education1 year ago

Capacity Building of Teacher handling Alternative Delivery Mode (ADM) classes in Zamboanga City Division

Unite for Education: Join PHEDRO as a Founding Member
Uncategorized1 year ago

Join PHEDRO as a Founding Member

Turkey’s Internationalization Of Higher Education Expectation, Experience, And Evaluation Of International Students_compressed
Assessment and Evaluation1 year ago

Turkey’s Internationalization of Higher Education: Expectation, Experience, and Evaluation of International Students

Continue Reading

Assessment and Evaluation

Writing PISA-Like Mathematics Items: The Case of Tertiary Math Instructors from a State University in the Philippines

PHEDRO

Published

on

By

Writing PISA-Like Mathematics Items: The Case of Tertiary Math Instructors from a State University in the Philippines

 

Authors

Mark Lester Garcia, Ateneo de Manila, Philippines

Derren Gaylo, Bukidnon State University, Philippines

Catherine P. Vistro-Yu, Ateneo de Manila, Philippines

Cite

“Garcia M., Gaylo D., and Vistro-Yu C. (2023). Writing PISA-Like Mathematics Items: The Case of Tertiary Math Instructors from a State University in the Philippines. Conference Paper: The 1st Mathematics and Mathematics Education International Conference (M2EIC) 2023. Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia, Bandung, Indonesia,June 24, 2023. Retrieved from: https://phedro.org/turkeys-internationalization-of-higher-education-expectation-experience-and-evaluation-of-international-students/

 

Abstract

International Large-Scale Assessments (ILSAs) such as PISA and TIMSS have become the prominent measure of mathematical literacy across countries and educational systems to date. As evidenced by released PISA and TIMSS items, math items in such ILSAs are characterized by an application of mathematics in a problem that supposedly simulates a real-world situation, where student test-takers are to use their mathematical knowledge and skills to come up with a solution. Math test items in such assessments are nested in contexts that have been defined in their assessment framework (e.g., the Personal, Occupational, Societal and Scientific context categories in PISA). This study followed the item-writing activities of four tertiary math instructors in the Philippines as they construct context-based math items. After undergoing an orientation on the PISA Math Assessment Framework, the respondents were asked to create PISA-like math items with a given set of specifications for content and context categories during an item-writing seminar-workshop. The data consists of transcripts from the focus-group discussion which was conducted after the seminar-workshop. The transcripts were then analyzed using thematic analysis. The results of this study showed that there were two themes that explain the phenomenon of item writing in the context of writing PISA-like math items. These themes are the phases of item-writing and the dimensions of item-writing. There were three phases and three dimensions captured from the participants’ narratives. Findings showed that the respondents primarily struggled with finding realistic contexts that fit the indicated item specifications based on the PISA categories. Additionally, the writers engaged in a problem-solving task similar to solving a puzzle as they created items that satisfied the content, context and process categories in the table of specifications. This study contributes to filling in the research gap on item-writing activities particularly those of math teachers in the Philippines- a country whose recent performance in the PISA 2018 and TIMSS 2019 was nothing short of dismal in terms of mathematical literacy.

Full Text

Writing PISA Like Mathematics Items The Case Of Tertiary Math Instructors From A State University In The Philippines Compressed

>>>>>>Read more related topics here<<<<<<

 

Continue Reading

Copyright © 2023 - Philippine Educational Research Organization (PHEDRO)